Greek influence on Indian astronomy

Greek influence lies at the heart of Indian astronomy (and, unfortunately, astrology).

[By the way, anyone interested in the interaction between Greek and Indian thought, needs to read ‘The Shape of Ancient Thought‘, by Thomas McEvilly.]

In the words of the 6th century Indian astronomer and mathematician Varahamihira, “The Greeks, though impure, must be honored since they were trained in sciences and therein, excelled others…..” He is echoed by the Garga Samhita, which says: “The Yavanas are barbarians, yet the science of astronomy originated with them and for this they must be reverenced like gods.”

The influence began with the Alexandrian conquest of North Western influence, but continued throughout the Greco-Roman period, as several astronomical texts are known to have been translated into Sanskrit in the early centuries of our era.

The influence is apparent by looking at the founders of Indian astronomy (passages taken from Encyclopedia of Ancient Natural Scientists: The Greek Tradition and its Many Heirs):

Yavanesvara (149/150 CE)

“Anonymous author in 149/150 CE of a Sanskrit prose translation of an unidentified Greek (probably Alexandrian) text on horoscopy, a translation known only from the surviving Sanskrit verse version Yavanajataka composed by Sphujidhvaja in 269/270. The title Yavanesvara then meant literally “lord of the Greeks,” evidently a high position among the Greek residents of western India under the western Ksatrapa rulers in the Saka or Skuthian dominion of the area… His text as known through the Yavanajataka became the chief inspiration for Indian horoscopic astrology”

Sphujidhvaja (269/270 CE)

“Composed in 269/270 CE a Sanskrit verse adaptation, entitled Yavanajataka (YJ) or Greek Horoscopy, of a prose translation from Greek by an anonymous Yavanesvara (“lord of the Greeks”)… clearly reveals its Greek origin, including many transliterated Greek technical terms.”

Minaraja (ca 300 – 325 CE)

“Minaraja was a yavanadhiraja, i.e., person of authority in the settlements of Greeks under the western Ksatrapas in what is now Gujarat and Rajasthan in western India. He wrote a long astrological compendium, the Vr.ddhayavanajataka, covering every subject of astrology, in 71 chapters. The work is based on Sphujidhvaja’s Yavanajataka and a lost work of Satya..”

[text] Paitamahasiddhanta (ca 425 CE?)

“The extant form of the Paitamahasiddhanta still contains many of the basic features of classical Indian astronomy that were apparently derived from Hellenistic spherical astronomy models. These include large-integer period relations used to calculate mean celestial positions, planetary epicycles and equations for correcting mean positions on the assumption of circular orbits, and orbital sizes and geocentric distances. Their details reflect a rather chaotic mix of (among other things) Babylonian and Aristotelian notions invoked by various early Hellenistic theories that fell into oblivion after Ptolemy. Indian astronomers combined these concepts with other parameters and techniques in their astronomical tradition to produce the cosmological and computational models that became standard in siddhantas… appears to be the inspiration for much of the classical siddhanta tradition in Indian mathematical astronomy. The siddhanta is a standard treatise format that explains universal computations for all significant astronomical phenomena… The core siddhantas of the two earliest major schools or paksas of Indian astronomy (upon which the later schools are based) – namely, the Aryabhatiya of Aryabhata(ca 500 CE) in the Aryapaks.a and the Brahmasphutasiddhanta of Brahmagupta (628 CE) in the Brahmapaksa – both claim to follow a treatise of Brahma. Similarities in content strongly indicate this Paitamahasiddhanta as the treatise referred to in both cases. It is considered to be the founding text of the Brahmapaksa, although its original version has long been lost.”

Aryabhata (circa 500 AD)

“The planetary model used by Aryabhata is derived from a pre-Ptolemaic Greek model, which sought to preserve the Aristotelian principle of concentricity. The mean planet moves in a circle around the Earth, and centered around the mean planet are one or two epicycles, depending on whether the planet is one of the two luminaries or a star-planet. Pingree (DSB 15.590) believes that the mean motions of the planets in the Aryabhatıya, apparently unrelated to those of the Brahmapaksa, were derived from a Greek table of mean longitudes corresponding to noon on 21 March 499 CE.”

Varahamira (circa 550 AD)

“A descendant of Zoroastrian immigrants from Iran to India and a resident of the area near Ujjain, and a prolific writer, whose works cover all aspects of traditional Indian astrology and astronomy. His Pañcasiddhantika is a summary of five astronomical works current at his time, but now lost: the Paitamahasiddhanta, which expounds astronomy influenced by Mesopotamia… the Vasisthasiddhanta, the Paulisasiddhanta, the Romakasiddhanta and the Suryasiddhanta, which all expound Indian versions of Greco-Babylonian astronomy. The Pañcasiddhantika is an important work both in shedding light on the Indian astronomical tradition prior to 500 CE, and in recording pre-Ptolemaic Greek astronomy from which the Indian tradition borrowed. Varahamihira authored three works on divination… On genethlialogy, Varahamihira authored two works… both based on the Indian adaptation of Greek material in the works of Sphujidhvaja and others.”

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Greek influence on Indian astronomy

  1. Pingback: Indian Philosophy « Johann Happolati

  2. Thanks for an interesting post. I confess I know little about the history of astronomy in India. You might be interested to know that the Greeks were also praised for their knowledge of science and the natural world, including of course astronomy, in ancient Jewish texts. The name Yavan is used for Greece there too.

    Greek ideas tended to persist in astronomy, as in many other fields, for many centuries, especially as the Ptolemaic model of the universe became an accepted theological dogma within the Church. We still use many of their constellation names. If you are interested in the history of astronomy, may I bring to your attention an article I’ve just published on my blog about the history of the constellations? You can find it here: http://michaelakay.wordpress.com/2012/02/27/society-in-the-sky-a-seventeenth-century-attempt-to-redraw-the-constellations/

    I would be interested to hear your thoughts!

    Thanks!

    Michael.

  3. It is my understanding that there are sophisticated astronomical references in Indian texts older than 350BC, and that the direction of influence is more likely to have been India -> Greece

    • You might be thinking of Vedic astronomical observations – but they were of the calendrical & religious sort.

      Here’s a quote from wikipedia on the kind of ‘astronomy’ that existed in India in the Vedic texts:

      Since the texts written by 1200 BCE were largely religious compositions the Vedānga Jyotiṣa has connections with Indian astrology and details several important aspects of the time and seasons, including lunar months, solar months, and their adjustment by a lunar leap month of Adhimāsa.[9] Ritus and Yugas are also described.[9] Tripathi (2008) holds that ‘ Twenty-seven constellations, eclipses, seven planets, and twelve signs of the zodiac were also known at that time.’

      I do think there were influences going both ways, especially in philosophy, even before Alexander – but as for astronomy proper in Greece, I would say they couldn’t have owed much to Indian thought.

  4. and wikkipedia is accurate. What a farce. By the way Hellenistic people wrote in Greek but were egyptians. Oh yes what about Pythagoras copying from sulba sutra and becoming a vegetarian, no influence from India. Check out anciant indian history before you make these assretions.
    The Hellenic, the real greeks contributed nothing to mathematics and thus could not be astronomers.Hellenistic ones were as they were an amalgam of Egypt and India, certainly not Greek

    • Reading my post will reveal that the source for the the extracts comes from the ‘Encyclopedia of Ancient Natural Scientists: The Greek Tradition and its Many Heirs.’

      I also already referred in the post to ‘The Shape of Ancient Thought’ by Thomas McEvilley, which I have also read and so I am aware of the influence of Indian thought on Greek thought as well as vice versa. Books like McEvilley’s, which are the most reliable guides to possible influences of Indian philosophy on Greek philosophy, also attribute the kinds of Greek influence on Indian thinking that I discussed above.

      As for the claim that “Hellenistic people wrote in Greek but were Egyptians” – that is absurd. The Hellenistic world was the entire Greek world from the conquests of Alexander to the rise of the Roman Empire, including the Ptolemaic and Seleucid Dynasties and others. Was Greece Egyptian? The Hellenistic world was a cosmopolitan world of many ethnicities – but the key was the bond of Greek language and culture – that is what the Hellenistic world was.

  5. So Wikepedia is your source of wisdom . How profound.Vanity always seems sacacious.
    Pythagoras copies Sulba Sutra , verbatum, philosophy of relativity and vegetrianism, asceticism lock stock anfd barrel, and of course Pythagoras was the biggest influence on Plato, but why should that matter. Nor the facts that Hercalitus’s philosophy of the flux appears out of the blue when in reality Samkhya, Jainism and Buddhism had already grappled with it for centuries. Remember my friend that Darius’s empire stretched from Taxilla to Sardis. Taxilla was the first university. General Vishtahspa was trained by the Brahmins, but all this means nothing to you maybe yo should work with Fox news and promulagte canards as wisdom.
    It was the incomplete understanding of Indian philosophy that killed Greek thought where the had no understanding either of mathematics or of abstractions or relativity.
    Astronomy was Babylonian not Greek and it was enhanced and improved in India, not Greece

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s